Vacation rentals in Horse Thief Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Horse Thief Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Cabin in Black Hills

Seldom Inn Guest House

Seldom Inn Guest House is located in the central Black Hills close to Mt Rushmore, Crazy Horse, Custer and Deadwood. The cabin is surrounded by ponderosa pines and sheer rock cliffs where often eagles soar, this spot is truly a bit of heaven on earth! We want you to know that we’re doing our part to help our Airbnb guests stay safe by cleaning and disinfecting frequently touched surfaces (light switches, doorknobs, cabinet handles, remotes, etc.) before you check-in. Welcome! Enjoy your stay!

Guest favorite

Guesthouse in Rapid City

Stoneridge Ranch

Looking for something off the beaten path to enjoy some peace/quiet? We’re just that, tucked away in the beautiful Black Hills only 30min from Rapid City & several favorite attractions: Mt Rushmore, Reptile Gardens, Bear Country, Needles Highway, Rushmore Caves + many more. Our property has opportunity to see lots of wildlife(deer, turkeys) and including our animals: a horse, a pony, 2 goats, 2 dogs & 2 cats. Runners take advantage of the gravel/paved roads for a scenic/peaceful run.

Guest favorite

Cabin in Hill City

Hideaway Cabin near Rochford

Nestled on a pine filled hillside is the Hideaway Cabin, a secluded A-frame with loft & Deck. It is perfect for 2, fine for 4 ! It is NOT IN HILL CITY, it's by ROCHFORD WE DO NOT HAVE: CELL SERVICE ( landline is available for emergencies) WE DO NOT HAVE: WIFI (very limited availability). WE DO NOT HAVE: Noisy neighbors & traffic ! This property affords quiet and privacy. About the only thing you will hear after 8:00 PM is an occasional coyote call !

Guest favorite

Tiny home in Custer

Black Hills Rambler-Tiny House

If you have ever wanted to try out "tiny living" our adorable tiny house is perfect. This hand built tiny home is situated on our family property, but away from the main house to give you the privacy you are looking for. While giving you the opportunity to unplug, the Rambler is surrounded by beautiful national forest but is also ideally located just 3.5 miles from the town of Custer, SD. Easy access to Hwy 16/385 and close to all the beauty that the Black Hills to offer.

Guest favorite

Tent in Rapid City

the Still House

**Check out my other two tents** www.airbnb.com/h/golddigger www.airbnb.com/h/roughrider This is how luxury camping should be. You'll be relaxing in your own private 16 x 13 ft wall tent with attached deck overlooking gorgous forested mountains. Your comfortable luxurious bed is furnished with fresh linens, fluffy duvet, and perfect pillows. Everything you need is here, just bring your clothing and food. CAUTION: This tent has steep trails leading to it and the bathroom!

Guest favorite

Guest suite in Hill City

Pine Mountain Rest

Come find a restful space in the Heart of the Hills. After a busy day exploring all that the Black Hills have to offer you will find a quiet place to relax, fix your meals and rest for another day of adventure. Relax on the deck and listen to the Hill City 1880 train whistle as it returns from its final run. Located in Hill City we are in the heart of everything you want to do. Mickelson Bike Trail runs through town. Mount Rushmore and Crazy Horse are within 15 miles.

Guest favorite

Farm stay in Rapid City

Luxury Ranch Stay

Be our guest on 40 private and fully gated acres. From all windows of the house you can watch 2 horses and cattle grazing through the meadow. The evening sunsets are magical with deer & turkeys wandering through. Relax under the stars at our fire pit (all supplies provided). Let your kids run wild with water guns & a water fall pond to refill at! Located right off HWY 16 makes you only 10 minutes to downtown Rapid City and 20 minutes to Mt. Rushmore!

Guest favorite

Rental unit in Custer

Journeys End cozy Apartment attached to house

Cozy apartment attached to the main house, queen bed, full sized couch bed, large shower, mini kitchen with sink, microwave, refrigerator, coffee pot, toaster. Deck outside--gas grill and patio furniture. Located on 26 acres of pine forest, meadow and mt. Rock shop on property. Lots of space for rest, relaxation, or hiking. Access to children's playground, mountaintop deck and hiking trails.

Guest favorite

Cabin in Hermosa

Beautiful Black Hills Cabin Centrally Located.

Beautiful Black Hills Cabin Centrally located on Hwy 40 West in Hermosa SD. This property is within 30 min of Keystone/Mt Rushmore, Hill City, Custer/Crazy Horse. Enjoy the Amazing views of the Hills and the abundance of wildlife from the covered patio. Two Bedrooms with Queen Beds. One large bathroom with walk in shower. Fully Furnished kitchen with all amenities, and Washer and Dryer.

Guest favorite

Loft in Custer

Downtown Loft

We invite you to stay with us in downtown Custer. This unique location is within walking distance to all of the great shops, award winning restaurants, and exciting music venues. Our aim is to offer you a comfortable place to lay your head after long days of travel and exploring. No matter your preference Custer is centrally located to all of the attraction the Paha Sapa has to offer.

Guest favorite

Rental unit in Custer

Black Hills Lodge Rental

Studio apartment with kitchen, bathroom, living room, and private entrance above detached garage on scenic lot in Custer, SD. 15 minutes from Downtown Custer, 18 minutes to Crazy Horse, and 35 minutes to Mount Rushmore. Additional cots available. There is a listing for a hot tub but actually it is a Jacuzzi because there is no Jacuzzi explanation in the Airbnb details

Guest favorite

Guest suite in Custer

The View at Bear Rock (Full Guest Suite)

This guest suite includes; cozy private rooftop deck that looks over the Rocky Knulls Golf Course, Queen bed, mini-fridge and microwave beautifully renovated shower and and bathroom. Within minutes from local food and bars and major local attractions.Mount Rushmore, Crazy Horse, Custer State Park all within very close distance as well.Also has cable TV and WiFi !!